I'm just completing the rebuild of the top end of my 1960 99 (necessitated by the partial seizure of one piston) and as it is the first time I've ever ventured inside a Dommie engine I followed the excellent Mick Hemmings engine-rebuild video. Now that I've got it all back together I'm rather reluctant to try firing it up as, when I kick it over with the plugs out to pump some oil round the engine, I'm aware of a pronounced and rather disturbing 'clanking' sound from within. Also, even with the plugs out, it takes a lot of effort to kick it over as it's pretty stiff (could that just be the new pistone and rings perhaps?)
I did this work with the engine still in the frame so, to get the pushrods in, I had to hold them in the head, poke the lower ends into the holes in the barrel then lower the head and hope the rods seated properly on the cam followers. Do they do this automatically? Can they 'mis-seat'? (Mick Hemmings has the luxury of working with the engine on a special stand on his workbench and is able to insert the rods into the barrel before lowering the head on to them.)
I then had the well-documented nightmare of locating the top ends on to the ends of the rocker arms which, with the help of the Hemmings rubber band trick, I 'think' I eventually (after about five attempts) achieved. Having tightened everything down, I set the tappets (6 and 8 thou as per) and, heeding Mick's advice, noted that there are equal amounts of thread showing above each of the tappet locking nuts. But still this worrying 'clanking' sound.
Any thoughts, observations, ideas, words of reassurance or comfort? All responses eagerly awaited as I want to get it running again but don't want to risk trashing the engine by ignoring what may well be a warning by the engine itself of something that I may have inadvertently got wrong (such as a pushrod that's not properly seated for example.) Help!
Do they do this automatica…
- Log in to post comments
My bet is the rocker ball…
My bet is the rocker ball not seated in the rod top. I've heard that noise too...All four top ends should be visible with a small torch. It is as John says possible that the bottom is mis-seated in the tappet hole. I slacken it all, run back the tappet adjusters, and lift the rods and drop them and twiddle them so they definitely sit down, then tip each rocker away from the valve stem and over on to each rod before drawing the head down.
- Log in to post comments
I agree with David, its do…
I agree with David, its done that to me too. ==bent pushrod , and it ran too.
- Log in to post comments
Thanks for the responses g…
Thanks for the responses gentlemen. I didn't disturb either the camshaft or the camchain John so I'm reasonably confident that the valves and pistons are keeping a respectful distance between themselves.
I suppose my gut feeling is in line with what you're suggesting David but, having achieved book tappet settings with nothing untoward being indicated by the comparitive positions of the tappet locking screws, I'd (perhaps wrongly) assumed that all must be well with the seating of the rod ends over the rocker balls. My problem is compounded by the fact that the bike's got a full fairing fitted and, try as I might, I really can't see the inlet valve rod ends (although I can just about get a squint at the ends of the exhaust rods).
I've now seen your comment too Robert and it is starting to look like another semi-stripdown to check the pushrod seatings. Interesting (and frightening) that you managed to run yours with the top end(s) unseated. Yikes!
- Log in to post comments
hi howard it looks like yo…
hi howard it looks like you may have them in at the top if you have the right amount of up and down play if you tug the rocker up and down but it may be incorrect at the other end,if you lift the head again to check also make sure the followers are not damaged on the cup at the top,if its OKhave the head raised a little on wood blocks its best to put a drop of oil down the push rod holes and if you try to lift a pushrod with your finger tips you can then feel the pushrod try lift the cam follower with the suctionyou dont get this if its not in the cup thendrop down the head and check top end with a torch anduse a small bit of a wire to trapthe pushrodwith the rocker thats it sorted
all the best Lawrence
- Log in to post comments
Mine was not located in th…
Mine was not located in the rocker ,but was wedged against the side of the head. It still managed to open the valve and when removed was bent at the end. I would remove the adjuster to allow movement and look across the head with a torch and engage the rod/rocker with a bit of bent wire. Take the fairing off!!. Too heavy anyway ,get a Givvi screen or similar.
- Log in to post comments
Thanks for the tips Lawren…
Thanks for the tips Lawrence and Robert; it's all rather in line with my own forebodings in the matter. Ah, well, I'll set about unscrewing everything and proceeding as you suggest (although I will be keeping the fairing, thank you Robert, but I may decide to remove it temporarily to let the dog see the rabbit, so to speak.)
- Log in to post comments
Up to recently i had a ful…
Up to recently i had a full Avonaire on my 99. It had the correct fittings for a featherbed and could be removed in 10 minuits without taking anything else off, with the bike on its centerstand on a bit of 4x2 it would just slide off over the fully vallenced mudguard and wheel.The fairing was too heavy (for me) and spoilt the feel of the bike. A 20 year old memory says you look through the exhaust side to see the inlet rod/rocker fit.?
- Log in to post comments
Regrettably, my fairing in…
Regrettably, my fairing installation is not quite so accommodating, requiring front wheel and mudguard removal to get the thing off and, understandably, I'm not too eager to go to those lengths just to get a squint at the ends of the rockers so I'll probably try a bit of legerdemain with a small mirror first. Promises to provide hours of fun.
- Log in to post comments
I don't see how you can l…
I don't see how you can locate the pushrods with a fairing attached. It's a guddle at the best of times. I think you will just have to bite the bullet and get the fairing off. Probably quicker in the end. For a couple of years I ran a Deauville for winter bad weather. Great fairing butaccessability for maintenance was a nightmare. Eventually I sold it.The Norton generally avoids the joy of winter rain and muckas I have a BSA with an Avon 'badger nose' handlebar fairing. Great device, even keeps your knees dry and no accessability problems.
Don't forget, if it's not going well, stop and have a cup of tea. Amazing how things tend to work after that.
- Log in to post comments
What type of fairing have…
What type of fairing have you got Howard?, I did think i would have to take out wheel/mudguard (a right game!) but on the Avon there is a small removable panel at the bottom front which just allows it to slide off.If it all gets too much ,half a bottle of Merlot sorts it out.
- Log in to post comments
Further very sound advice…
Further very sound advice there gentlemen - especially with regard to the cup of tea and Merlot chaser. That's my kind of spannering!
I'm now reasonably reassured that all the pushrods are in fact properly seated as I discovered that, by poking a finger into the exhaust tappet access holes, I can actually touch each of the pushrods and, with the relevant valve closed, I found that each rod spins smoothly when I push it with a fingertip (a benefit of having small hands I suppose). Still doesn't explain the 'clank' though but I'm now sufficiently emboldened to try a tentative start up, albeit with a thumb hovering over the 'kill' switch for a rapid cessation if it sounds nasty. What could possibly go wrong?
My fairing is an Avon too Robert and has the removable panel but I'm fairly sure that it ain't quite wide enough to clear the mudguard. Still, I'm now hopeful that removal won't be necessary. I've attached a picture of the bike with its fairing. By the way, Gordon, I like your word 'guddle' - never come across it before but I shall make a point of dropping it into conversation some time and see what effect it has!
Attachments
2013_0730dommy99-with-fairing0004-jpg
- Log in to post comments
My, what a beauty! It real…
My, what a beauty! It really does look all of a piece, doesn't it?
I am a bit worried that you don't know your pushrods from your conrods, but I'm sure you do really!
Good luck with it.....
- Log in to post comments
Oops! (Where's the red-fa…
Oops! (Where's the red-face smilie when you need it?) Write out 500 times 'I mean pushrods, not conrods. What the hell's wong with me these days anyway?' Thanks for your kind and gentlemanly correction Ian. Thanks also for your kind words about the bike.
- Log in to post comments
Previously howard_thompson…
Previously howard_thompson wrote:
Oops! (Where's the red-face smilie when you need it?) Write out 500 times 'I mean pushrods, not conrods. What the hell's wong with me these days anyway?' Thanks for your kind and gentlemanly correction Ian. Thanks also for your kind words about the bike.
hi howard that sure is a smart de-lux dommi hope she run's ok iwill keep my fingers crossed.
- Log in to post comments
Nice colour scheme, can't…
Nice colour scheme, can't see any reason why your fairing should not slide off,if you get the angle right. Its a year or so younger than the one on mine(i do have one like yours in the rafters) Your side panels are from another (smaller) deluxe ,They should enclose the carb completely, But i think yours are more practical. Your bike has loads of non standard stuff ,as i'm sure you know ,mine has plenty of mod's but all hidden away.Been having ignition problems ,probably dud battery,14 years old Yuasa! is that a record?.My 99 clanked a bit ,piston slap,made much worse by the fairing.If the piston piston pins are a bit tight (should float hot) it will clank when cold ,If it goes away when hot ,its slap.Slap seems to start with about 41/2 thou clearance ,but I would not run with less.
- Log in to post comments
Nice to see what mine must…
Nice to see what mine must have looked like when it left the factory (No 85787) except mine was red and white. The enclosure was long gone when I bought it back in 1969 (you didn't get much for £30 even then) and these days it looks just like any scruffy well-used SS. Suits me!
- Log in to post comments
Previously robert_tuck wro…
Previously robert_tuck wrote:
Your side panels are from another (smaller) deluxe
That's an interesting point Robert. They're certainly not Jubilee or Navigator panels as those have the lower mounting fasteners in a different position. Someone mentioned in an earlier thread that the panel sizes changed on De Luxe Dommies over the production run but I'm afraid I don't know anything about that.
If the piston piston pins are a bit tight (should float hot) it will clank when cold
Another very interesting point and maybe, just maybe, the explanation for my 'clanking' on kicking it over as the gudgeon pins that came with the new pistons are an extremely tight fit in the conrods (at last! I knew if this thread ran long enough the malapropism in the title would eventually make sense). The pins fit so tightly in fact that I had to warm up the conrods to get them in. So, with gudgeon pins tight in the conrods, would the clanking be wear in the big end bearings making itself heard perhaps? I must say, the more I think about it the more I'm convinced that you've identified the problem/idiosyncracy (take your pick).
The battery on mine is on its last knockings too but as my bike has magneto ingnition it's of little real relevance.
Anyway, thanks very much for your insightful thoughts Robert, I shall now 'boldly go' as someone once said and try starting it. Thanks also Lawrence and Gordon for your kind words.
- Log in to post comments
Previously howard_thompson…
Previously howard_thompson wrote:
Previously robert_tuck wrote:
Your side panels are from another (smaller) deluxe
That's an interesting point Robert. They're certainly not Jubilee or Navigator panels as those have the lower mounting fasteners in a different position. Someone mentioned in an earlier thread that the panel sizes changed on De Luxe Dommies over the production run but I'm afraid I don't know anything about that.
If the piston piston pins are a bit tight (should float hot) it will clank when cold
Another very interesting point and maybe, just maybe, the explanation for my 'clanking' on kicking it over as the gudgeon pins that came with the new pistons are an extremely tight fit in the conrods (at last! I knew if this thread ran long enough the malapropism in the title would eventually make sense). The pins fit so tightly in fact that I had to warm up the conrods to get them in. So, with gudgeon pins tight in the conrods, would the clanking be wear in the big end bearings making itself heard perhaps? I must say, the more I think about it the more I'm convinced that you've identified the problem/idiosyncracy (take your pick).
The battery on mine is on its last knockings too but as my bike has magneto ingnition it's of little real relevance.
Anyway, thanks very much for your insightful thoughts Robert, I shall now 'boldly go' as someone once said and try starting it. Thanks also Lawrence and Gordon for your kind words.
I fitted the fairing manyyears ago but the bike has got less and less use being the most cumbersum of my stable,needing a bike to carry my sons in the IOM I was glumly thinking of the hassle of removing the mudguard when a memory from 1968! popped up.A siezure at 95mph on the MI (overheated!) Prompted me to do a roadside strip,Off with fairing,head and barrels , On the Motorway. A bit of filing and back together to clank off home. And i did not remove the wheel or mudguard.Heartenned by this memory I tried what does look impossible, And it will go,Just.If the pin is that tight in the rod I would be concerned, Although std practise in some older car engines I would worry that with Norton tolerances a tight pin/rod will not allow the piston to find a comfy position in what could easily be out of parralel bores.(you did sieze ?) Little end will need reaming if the pins fit right to the piston,(oval small end?). You could be right about the side panels, They may have altered them to fit the mythical 650 DL which had a DD head.
- Log in to post comments
I used 99 pins in 650 pist…
I used 99 pins in 650 pistons and they were too tight, Can't remember how i got over this ,probably fine carborundem paper !, Don't use this on a bush.Did it sieze with the mag in place?,If so check the timing on both sides.Clanking on kickover sounds worrying.
- Log in to post comments
I'm going to try to post…
I'm going to try to post a picture of my DL ,only fair that you can nitpick on my bike too.
- Log in to post comments
Plenty more food for thoug…
Plenty more food for thought there Robert. Re the seizure, it had clearly happened before my ownership as the bike was running well enough, albeit with pronounced smoking from the nearside silencer on the overrun. I stripped it down to investigate the problem and found fairly severe scuffing on the piston skirt and a mild scuff (easily removed with a light hone) on the cylinder bore. I will check the timing on each side though.
Your cautionary note about tight gudgeon pins on a Norton has now given me pause for thought however and I'll probably abandon my gung ho intention of giving it a 'what the hell' start up. Although the original gudgeon pins are (unsurprisingly) a comfortable fit in the little ends, presumably that will make them a loose fit in the new pistons, otherwise I'd just be inclined to use them again instead of the pins that came with the new pistons. Any thoughts on that?
- Log in to post comments
New pistons need new pins…
New pistons need new pins ,I expect you heated the pistons to fit the pins ,when they should slide in,Its possible that the use and seizure has ovalled the small end, Were they both tight? My 99 came to me in the same state, You could try the old pins for fit in the new pistons ,but pins do tire out so its better to ream the rod.I do aprove of your "interpretation" of the Dove grey , very gay!, Do you get asked for a "99 with a flake"!.Dove grey is a drab colour.
- Log in to post comments
Didn't need to heat the p…
Didn't need to heat the pistons to get the pins in Robert, they slid in easily enough, it was just the little ends that needed warming up. Both pins were a tight fit so I don't suspect ovality as the problem. The bushes are sleeved too so reaming is, presumably, out of the question (I'm a bit out of my depth, I'm afraid, when it comes to those sort of considerations). Also, any work on the little ends would necessitate removal of the engine, I imagine, which I am eager to avoid if at all possible.
Interesting description you have for the colour scheme - the original Jubilee advertising urged would-be punters to 'Go gay on a Jubilee!' Perhaps the Norton copywriters were just many years ahead of their time.
- Log in to post comments
-Bushed small ends are sim…
-Bushed small ends are simple to ream ,you can buy an adjustable hand reamer from Tracy Tools ,a bit of rag in the case to catch any waste .Not expensive.Easy. Motor should not be tight,Good opportunity to check for problem with rings, Did you check the ring gaps in the Bore? I had an oversize one in my set. ,What type of oil rings ? some can cause problems if expander not butting.Where are you located?.
- Log in to post comments
-Bushed small ends are sim…
-Bushed small ends are simple to ream ,you can buy an adjustable hand reamer from Tracy Tools ,a bit of rag in the case to catch any waste .Not expensive.Easy. Motor should not be tight,Good opportunity to check for problem with rings, Did you check the ring gaps in the Bore? I had an oversize one in my set. ,What type of oil rings ? some can cause problems if expander not butting.Where are you located?.
- Log in to post comments
Well, it all sounds simple…
Well, it all sounds simple enough when you put it like that. I'll have a look at the Tracy Tools website and also google 'reaming for idiots', see what comes up.
I did check the ring gaps before fitting and they were within specified range (just). The oil rings are the solid type, rather than the three-parters shown in the Hemmings video. I'm in Surrey, by the way.
- Log in to post comments
Hi Howard, I'm about 30 m…
Hi Howard, I'm about 30 min ride from you, If you want to PM a phone no, I will pop round (on my trusty 99DL!) and listen to it. Seems a shame to rip it down again without giving it a go. BoB.
- Log in to post comments
One other thought,could it…
One other thought,could it be that a cam follower is sticky (swopped over?) and is snapping back onto the cam. Did you have it re-bored or honed ? Its possible to mix them (I did!).
- Log in to post comments
I didn't remove the cam f…
I didn't remove the cam followers Bob, although I did have the bores honed (with the cam followers still in situ). Mysteriouser and mysteriouser, as they say.
- Log in to post comments
Previously howard_thompson…
Previously howard_thompson wrote:
I didn't remove the cam followers Bob, although I did have the bores honed (with the cam followers still in situ). Mysteriouser and mysteriouser, as they say. Its possible that some abrasive or honing debris has got in the follower tunnel and causing them to be stiff?.
- Log in to post comments
Well, it is a thought I su…
Well, it is a thought I suppose, although I do think it unlikely. I still believe that the stiff gudgeon pin/conrod fit is the probable culprit.
- Log in to post comments
Eu-flaming-reka! (Greek fo…
Eu-flaming-reka! (Greek for 'I am a plonker', apparently.) I have now established the source of the clanking sound when I kick the engine over and it's nothing whatsoever to do with pushrods, conrods, curtain rods or stair rods. It's merely the kickstart arm making slight contact with the not-quite-correctly-positioned offside silencer at the botton of its stroke. Duh!
To say I was relieved to, at last, suss that out would be to understate matters somewhat, as I had visions of having to pull the whole lot apart again to rectify some idiotic assembly goof that I feared I must have made. Not so, I'm delighted to report. The bike started easily and runs like a good 'un. Right, now for a spot of running in!
- Log in to post comments
Good news!, If as you say…
Good news!, If as you say the pins were an easy fit in the pistons then they will float as they should .I have been struggling with ignition problems and stupidly forgot that dirty plugs cannot be relied upon to work even after the cause of the problem has been fixed.Must be old age !.Now that my bike has had some real hard work the compression has realy increased and the piston slap appears to have dissapeared,strange.
- Log in to post comments
Looking at the shot of you…
Looking at the shot of your bike ,you will have to play around a bit to get clearance, you have pipes,silencers and brackets all not standard .Not that this is unusual,I don't think anyone makes a correct replacement for any of these parts, The nearest correct look is a set of Siamese pipes (an option at that time ) which at least gives a kick up under the gearbox,mated to a cheroot silencer ,The orriginal pipes dropped down directly from the port, had a nice curved line a bit like a model 7 and a noticable kick up under the gearbox and cheroot silencers which were high enough to give a problem with the wheel spindle.
- Log in to post comments
I must say, Bob, I didn't…
I must say, Bob, I didn't realise that my bike had as much non-standard kit as you describe but I'm happy to bow to your superior knowledge in the matter. I previously achieved clearance for the kickstarter by judicious use of a large jubilee clip round the pipe and a lower chassis rail but, having taken particular care in replacing the exhaust system, I (wrongly) assumed that it would no longer be necessary. Yer lives 'n' learns, innit?
- Log in to post comments
A crumb of comfort (other…
A crumb of comfort (other than we all have these Eureka moments from time to time). I still have the original silencer mounts and still have had the kickstart clip the offside silencer from time to time over the years. Various combinations of replacement silencer and kickstart will cause it. A large ball pein hammer has been brought into play on these occasions.Regarding siamese exhausts. Removing and replacing them once they have seen a few years use can be a mite challenging. It can result in somewhat mangled exhaust port threads. Not so good.
Great to hear your bike is up and running. My one just had its annual wash and maintenance - one spoke replaced and a new wheel bearing. Not too bad for a year's thrashing.
- Log in to post comments
Hi Gordon, I did try to ge…
Hi Gordon, I did try to get some new pipes but found the suppliers considered that one set of pipes was right to fit the 88 and 99, when Norton thought it needed two sets,also the pipes were just a collection of straights and bends and headed upwards from the ports!. The siamese came from RGM,still a very poor fit and came with a collet fitting on one port that looked odd but should prove easier to remove ,The best bet is to re-furbish an old rusty set or get a stainless set made to measure.
- Log in to post comments
Oddly enough I have used A…
Oddly enough I have used Armour's universal stainless 88 & 99 pipes on both 88 & 99 and they ain't bad. Original factory exhausts must be a mite thin on the ground now. The ideal solution if you can get them.
- Log in to post comments
Do they do this automatically? Most times yes but
Can they 'mis-seat'? Yes
Clue is the adusters which you say are all equal so you should have no issues there.
The clanking sound needs investigating further, could be a valve hitting the piston but you may have to tear it down to check for witness marks/clues. Did you distrub the camshaft and/or cam chain.
A newly rebored engine is stiff to turn, so stiff sometimes on singles you cannot get a kick to start them until after the first start. I favour the dry bore method which gives this stiffness but aids quick ring seating.