Skip to main content
English French German Italian Spanish

Dominator 99 problems

Forums

Hi

I have a 1962 Dominator 99 which was converted to 12 Volt some years ago. Recently it has started to break down after running for 15 to 20 miles and seems to be missing on a cylinder on idle and during acceleration. I changed the plugs, plug caps and HT leads, coil, distributer cap, points and condenser. I also stripped the carb which was clean and cleaned the fuel tap. I checked the valve clearances, again these were fine all to no avail. I have noticed that there is an oil leak from somewhere in the vacinity of the breather when the engine is very hot. Another thing I noticed is that there is smoke being forced out under pressure from the joint just behind the dist. (photo attached) where it joins the timing cover when hot. I am running out of ideas and wondered if a blockage in the breather would cause these symptoms and if so how do you think this could be cleared.

I think that I may have made some progress. I did a compression test while hot and both cylinders are showing a healthy 100 psi with no loss. As I mentioned I have come to suspect the breather due to the perceived increase in engine pressure. I disconnected the breather pipe from the back of the engine where it enters the oil tank and stuck a one way valve on the end of the pipe and took it for another run. After another twenty miles I started to climb a steep hill and while the engine was under pressure I noticed a slight miss which was how the problem started originally. After a couple of hundred yards the miss disappeared and the bike ran and idled fine for another ten miles on the run home. What I did notice was some oil being blown out through the valve which I assume is normal as it was connected to the oil tank?. I checked the oil levels and all is fine. I have to say that this is a new one on me as I have experienced increased crankcase pressure in the past due to worn engines and all I have ever noticed was more oil on the ground.

TIA, PeterAttachments DSC00169.JPG
Permalink

Peter. You have completely changed the ignition system, so it would seem unlikely that it is an ignitioncomponent fault unless very coincidentally the same problem is manifest on the new part as the old part. You say there are signs of crankcase excessive pressure. To check the breather, fit a long plastic pipe to enable you to sit on the bike with the pipe in your mouth. Remove the plugs and slowly turn the engine over, with the kickstart and blow hard into the extended breather pipe. If you have a normal breather system which is working correctly you should be able to feel by the pressure in your mouth that air is being allowed to blow into the crankcase and then firmly stops as the disc valve rotates. If you can feel this timed operation then the breather is working normally.If not, it could be that the rotating disc has become damaged. (The driving "ears" have become worn off...unusual but possible).

The breather, if not working, will not cause a misfire though, but what can happen is that the crankcase pressure blows oil past the oil seal in the distributer shaft, and the oil travels along the internal parts and gets onto the points. An easy check is to see if oil is on the points.

You have reasonable compression (but not that good) with both sides equal, so the valves are probably seatingquite well.

Back to the ignition, are you sure the low voltage connections on the coil have not been reversed? Make sure the CB terminal does indeed go back to the points. Although a coil will work with the connections reversed it will only work well with them correctly connected, so you may well have a weak spark if reversed. Just as it is so easy, it would be an easy thing to change the spark plugs again for another new set, it just might be bad luck that one of them is the culprit.

Although unlikely as you say you have cleaned the petrol tap, it could be fuel supply problems. Check the fuel delivery rate from the tank at the fuel pipe at the carb end. It could even be the petrol cap air hole is blocked.

Les H

Permalink

Have you checked the charging system and battery to make sure you are getting 12V at the coils without any breakdown from AC to DC due to a dud rectifier?

Dominic

Permalink

Dominic

Checked the charging and it's working fine with a fully charged new battery.

Les

"To check the breather, fit a long plastic pipe to enable you to sit on the bike with the pipe in your mouth."

I have to say that I had no idea that there was a disc in the breathing system. I did as you suggested and it does seem to be opening and closing the breather as discribed although when closed it is possible blow a small amount through but it takes an effort. (does working on the disc require an engine strip?)

I did a second compression test when cold and the readings went to 120 on the left and 128 on the right cylinders.

"what can happen is that the crankcase pressure blows oil past the oil seal in the distributer shaft"

No oil coming into the distributer but the smoke escaping under pressure from the casings would seem to indicate that something odd is happening.

"Back to the ignition, are you sure the low voltage connections on the coil have not been reversed"

Checked again and all is fine. No work had been done near the coil before this problem started.

"Check the fuel delivery rate from the tank at the fuel pipe at the carb end. It could even be the petrol cap air hole is blocked."

The petrol cap was the first thing checked (actually I took off the cap to check if I had petrol..!!) The tap produces 1 pint in exactly three minutes, not sure if this seems a little slow?.

Permalink

If it was a fuelling problem it would manifest with a more difinite surging/hesitation. What do the plugs look like after a short ride?

Dominic

Permalink

Hi Dominic

Don't think it's fuel unless something is causing an intermittant blockage. The strange thing is that it takes 20 miles of normal riding before the problem shows. If it was fuel I would expect it to happen hot or cold. One thing I forgot to mention, on the return journey with the bike missing badly particularly when trying to pull away fron lights (sods law stated that I hit every red on the way home), I reved the bike far beyond what I normally would in sheer frustration and the problem cleared for the mile I had left..!!.

I tried it again today with the breather reconnected and sure enough it started to misbehave at the usual mileage. When it was idling badly I pulled off the breather pipe and the idle settled down to near normal. Unfortunately running with the pipe removed from the tank results in oil going everywhere. I checked the vent in the oil tank and it is clear.

Peter

Permalink

Previously wrote:

Hi Dominic

Don't think it's fuel unless something is causing an intermittant blockage. The strange thing is that it takes 20 miles of normal riding before the problem shows. If it was fuel I would expect it to happen hot or cold. One thing I forgot to mention, on the return journey with the bike missing badly particularly when trying to pull away fron lights (sods law stated that I hit every red on the way home), I reved the bike far beyond what I normally would in sheer frustration and the problem cleared for the mile I had left..!!.

I tried it again today with the breather reconnected and sure enough it started to misbehave at the usual mileage. When it was idling badly I pulled off the breather pipe and the idle settled down to near normal. Unfortunately running with the pipe removed from the tank results in oil going everywhere. I checked the vent in the oil tank and it is clear.

Peter

The pipe you are removing is the one from the motor to the oil tank? if so there should not be much if any actual oil coming out of that pipe. It should be vapour mostly. How much pressure is in that pipe when the bike is running? ie if you were to put your finger over the open end.

The return to the tank from the oil pump is pumping sufficiently I assume. At idle how does the return feed seem? Is it producing the usual spurt style on and off? it is a pity that one could not drain the sump as soon as the problem manifests to check the oil pump's scavenging function. How do the plugs look? perhaps you should check the plugs when it starts its problem as they may be oiling up. Does the bike smoke at all once the problems manifest?

So many questions. Apologies!

Dominic

Permalink

Hi Peter.Intermittent faults are a pain. At least you've learned that you have a timed breather system and your one is working normally and no work on it is required.

I cannot see how the breather system can affect the normal firing of an engine apart from keeping oil away from the combustion chamber and interfering with the firing, but I would almost rule this effect completely out, but see note at the end..

You could hard wire the the battery directly to the SW terminal of the coil (you could incorporate a switch in series too with the wire for extra convenience). This would illiminate all chances that your ignition wiring or ignition switch has some form of poor or intermittent connection.

Do this and report back, it will have to be a series of steps to locate the fault, otherwise you will chase around and around and not get anywhere.

BTW I don't know what is causingthe smoke from the crankcases, but you check the plugs for sooting up. I know you say you have reasonable compression, but an engine can still burn oil excessively if the oil scraper rings aren't working well. It would not cause smoke to blow from the engine though.

Les

Permalink

Previously wrote:

"The pipe you are removing is the one from the motor to the oil tank?"

Thats the one. The pressure is quite high and if I put my finger over the end it blows past. It is mainly vapour with some oil being forced through, enough to run down the side of the oil tank and onto the casings and frame after about 15 miles.

"The return to the tank from the oil pump is pumping sufficiently I assume. At idle how does the return feed seem?"

This seems fine with a healthy flow on idle when engine speed is increased it falls back a little but picks up again.

"How do the plugs look? perhaps you should check the plugs when it starts its problem as they may be oiling up. Does the bike smoke at all once the problems manifest?"

No problem with the plugs oiling up with no change in colour after a run. There is a little smoke from the exhausts when cold but this clears up as the engine is run.

"So many questions. Apologies!"

Please don't apologise as all the questions I have been getting are very interesting. I suspect that a question will lead to an "Aha" moment when I realise that I have missed the blindingly obvious.

Thanks again

Peter

Permalink

Previously wrote:

Hi Les

"Intermittent faults are a pain. At least you've learned that you have a timed breather system and your one is working normally and no work on it is required."

As I mentioned in my reply to Dominic all of the questions are interesting and thanks to yours I have learned something new about my breathing system.

"You could hard wire the the battery directly to the SW terminal of the coil (you could incorporate a switch in series too with the wire for extra convenience). This would illiminate all chances that your ignition wiring or ignition switch has some form of poor or intermittent connection."

I will try this as the ignition switch is about the only part of the system I have not replaced. A friend also mentioned the switch but as I was concentrating on parts which might be affected by heat it slipped my mind. I will get to it during the week and will let you know how I get on.

"BTW I don't know what is causingthe smoke from the crankcases, but you check the plugs for sooting up. I know you say you have reasonable compression, but an engine can still burn oil excessively if the oil scraper rings aren't working well. It would not cause smoke to blow from the engine though."

The plugs seem fine with no signs of oiling up. Have you ever heard of a valve sticking intermittently?. It was just something which crossed my mind.

Peter

Permalink

Previously wrote:

"The return to the tank from the oil pump is pumping sufficiently I assume. At idle how does the return feed seem?"

This seems fine with a healthy flow on idle when engine speed is increased it falls back a little but picks up again.

The feed at idle should be initially continuous and after a short time to spurt. The reason I am asking this is to check whether your scavenging pump is working correctly as a full sump of oil would cause the excessive pressure in the sump and may affect the firing as a result especially as it seems to take 20 mins for the problem to surface. The breather should not push oil out.

When last did you do an oil change? Does your model have the oil strainer at the bottom of the sump? If so is it clean?

Dominic

Permalink

Hi Peter. Your suggestion of sticking valves is a possibility. The exhaust valves will be the most likely. It can happen if the valve stem has carboned up. I've never know it myself to happen when running, but I've known the exhaust valve to stick open after leaving the bike not running for a long time. You might be able to seethe valve stems by removing the exhaust pipes and getting the valves on full lift. I can only imagine that the crud will be the point on the stem that is only just going into the valve guide at valve closure, and is also exposed to the exhaust carbon. It could be occassionaly causing some binding. If it is this area, there would have been a good chance that some contact has been made by the piston crown at TDC...not nice!

You might, repeat might,be able to,with a suitable tool (perhaps a bent screw driver with sharpened blade) scrape away the crud on the the valve stem. It will only be required at the the one small area as I have just described. I doubt if you willbe able to turn the valve in situ though to to get to the back of the stem.

As I said, I have never known this to happen but I guess it can happen. A full head service will be the best way to ulimately overcome the problem.

If the problem remains and all aspects of ignition and fueling have been totally certified as working normally, then this is a worthwhile check as it is a possibilty.

Les

Permalink

Just adding aCORRECTION here: I've just thought that if if the sticking is just before the valve fully closes, then there will be less chance for the valve to come into contact with the piston which is a relief. I suggested there was a "Good chance" that piston contact would be made, but as I have justsaid, it is not that likely, so good news!

Les

Permalink

Previously wrote:

Hi Peter. Your suggestion of sticking valves is a possibility. The exhaust valves will be the most likely. It can happen if the valve stem has carboned up. I've never know it myself to happen when running, but I've known the exhaust valve to stick open after leaving the bike not running for a long time. You might be able to seethe valve stems by removing the exhaust pipes and getting the valves on full lift. I can only imagine that the crud will be the point on the stem that is only just going into the valve guide at valve closure, and is also exposed to the exhaust carbon. It could be occassionaly causing some binding. If it is this area, there would have been a good chance that some contact has been made by the piston crown at TDC...not nice!

You might, repeat might,be able to,with a suitable tool (perhaps a bent screw driver with sharpened blade) scrape away the crud on the the valve stem. It will only be required at the the one small area as I have just described. I doubt if you willbe able to turn the valve in situ though to to get to the back of the stem.

As I said, I have never known this to happen but I guess it can happen. A full head service will be the best way to ulimately overcome the problem.

If the problem remains and all aspects of ignition and fueling have been totally certified as working normally, then this is a worthwhile check as it is a possibilty.

Les

Just adding aCORRECTION here: I've just thought that if if the sticking is just before the valve fully closes, then there will be less chance for the valve to come into contact with the piston which is a relief. I suggested there was a "Good chance" that piston contact would be made, but as I have justsaid, it is not that likely, so good news!

Les

Permalink

Hi Dominic

âThe feed at idle should be initiallycontinuous and after a short time to spurt.â

That seems to be what is happeningalthough at higher revs the returning pressure seem to drop a little.

It is interesting that you should mention wet sumping as when speaking tothe owner of a BSA A10 he mentioned similar symptoms to those that I amexperiencing. Of course being completely focused on the ignition system I didnot give his comments too much consideration . This morning Ichecked the bike which has been standing for 24 hours and I drained off ? pintof oil.

When I bought the bike some years agofrom the UKI was on holiday when it was delivered. I came home after it had been lying upfor a couple of weeks to a garage floor covered in oil. I have had no realproblems since with wet sumping as it is in daily use.

âWhen last did you do an oil change?â

Oil was changed less than 200 milesago. I have been using Castrol GTX from the time I got the bike. I did switch back to Castrol 50W for a short time but the engine seemed much more noisy so I reverted to GTX although this now seem to have been discontinued here.

âDoesyour model have the oil strainer at the bottom of the sump?â

I have fitted the Norvil magneticsump plug which has a strainer and both are completely clear.

Les

I remember peering into the chamberwhile the exhaust was removed when I first bought the bike and was surprisedhow clean it was. The dealer who sold it to me was unable so supply any historybut a considerable amount of work and money had been spent on it before I camealong with an engine that you could eat your dinner off. It had all theappearance of an overhauled engine although I was unable to confirm this as Inever received a reply to my letter to the previous owner. I will try out yoursuggestion of by passing the ign. switch next just to eliminate thatpossibility.

BTW I see what you mean in your earlier post about the way repliesseem to be all over the place. It can make checking replies a tad confusing tosay the least. I was tempted to open a new topic but was afraid that this wouldonly make things worse.

Thanks again,

Peter

Permalink

I wondered whether the scavenging effects of the pump were inadequate while the bike was riding which may fill the sump up to unacceptablelevels for riding. It seems odd that oil is being pushed out of the breather while you ride. Either there is too much crankcase pressure or the sump is slowly filling up. I have had the experience that too much crankcase pressure with weak oil scrapers will cause poor running - however the plugs/s would look damp with oil which is not your case. We need Sherlock Holmes!

Permalink

Hi

had simlar problem on my 500 twin it was down to loose head bolts around the pushrods. leaking combustion pressure into sump through pushrod channels.

causing back pressure pushing oil out everywhere.

also it would only run cool with addative mixed in with fuel. if i didnt put addative in it ran very hot with simlar problem that you describe

it must boil the fuel evaporating then when you stop it all cools down hence return of fuel and off you go again

Baz

Permalink

Baz

Thatâs an interesting comment on the loose head bolts and although mine seemtight I will torque them down and see what happens. How did you cure theproblem, did you just tighten down the head or did you replace the headgasket?.

Les

Just before the crash when my last entry disappeared I thinkthat you mentioned that you thought that I had discounted the sticking valvetheory. I am coming to the conclusion that the problem is mechanical as I havereplaced all the electrical components and bypassed the ign. switch, so this isstill a possibility. The fact that there is an increase in oil leaks fromsomewhere near the chaincase after a hard run but not after a shorter run intothe city also seems to indicate a buildup of pressure.

I was also wondering if there were any problems associated with changing theoil pump ( other than the cost ) that I should be aware of. Will pulling offthe cover have any effect on the chain tension?. Speaking of chains I decidedto replace the rear chain but the nearest I can find here is a Japanese size of520 as the distributers here have never come across 5/8 X 1/4 before. The onlything is that the one I got is a full 5mm wider than the 1 1/2 cm on presentlyfitted. I normally buy from Norvil but the weight of a chain makes postageexpensive.

Thanks again,

Peter

Permalink

Previously wrote:

Hi . i just tightened the head down . when i say the bolts were loose you would have had to use spanner to move them. they simply wernt torqued up right .

the engine would misfire on one pot and throw smoke out on over run .after i tightened head it seemed to cure all. back pressure ect.

i am no means an expert just thought it might help .

Baz

Baz

Thatâs an interesting comment on the loose head bolts and although mine seemtight I will torque them down and see what happens. How did you cure theproblem, did you just tighten down the head or did you replace the headgasket?.

Les

Just before the crash when my last entry disappeared I thinkthat you mentioned that you thought that I had discounted the sticking valvetheory. I am coming to the conclusion that the problem is mechanical as I havereplaced all the electrical components and bypassed the ign. switch, so this isstill a possibility. The fact that there is an increase in oil leaks fromsomewhere near the chaincase after a hard run but not after a shorter run intothe city also seems to indicate a buildup of pressure.

I was also wondering if there were any problems associated with changing theoil pump ( other than the cost ) that I should be aware of. Will pulling offthe cover have any effect on the chain tension?. Speaking of chains I decidedto replace the rear chain but the nearest I can find here is a Japanese size of520 as the distributers here have never come across 5/8 X 1/4 before. The onlything is that the one I got is a full 5mm wider than the 1 1/2 cm on presentlyfitted. I normally buy from Norvil but the weight of a chain makes postageexpensive.

Thanks again,

Peter

Permalink

Peter. I would now advise you to get a Norton expert to check over your bike,The scavenge side of the oil pump is the more likely side to get damaged (by debris pick up) and thus your pump might have a problem keeping the sump dry. Whether this will be the reason for the misfire looks tenuous though, but not completely impossible if all the other worn engine parts add up in the right (wrong) way. Maybe you now consider a complete engine rebuild?

The oil pump renewal is straight foward and will not effect the chain tension by removing the timing cover but one would imagine you would take the opportunity to adjust the chain tension/slack at this time but you will require a cutaway coverfor better accuracy.

As for the chain, the Jap system expresses the size in eights, so 530 is 5/8 x 3/8 and your new 520 one should be ok at 5/8 x 2/8 (1/4) What you might have is the extra heavy duty one. These have thicker side plates and create a wider chain, (roller width remains the same though)It could be that you have a 525 chain by mistake which is the same as a 5/8 x 5/16 (8/2.5) and thus wider by 1/16".

Les

Permalink

Hi Peter. Have you checked the dizzy shaft and advance mech for looseness in the bearings. See if point opening varies under under side pressure. This is common in old dizzys.Your problems say ignition ,good even compression rules out valve piston and gasket.

 


Norton Owners Club Website by 2Toucans