Skip to main content
English French German Italian Spanish

Piston rings

Have owners of earlier Nortons fitted more effective oil control rings instead of the standard cast iron slotted type? I'm about to attempt to improve the surface finish of my bore using either a flexhone or a spring loaded stone type hone, but I need to decide whether to re fit existing rings, or replace like for like, or try something more modern. Since it has exposed valves, the top end isn't flooded so I doubt of that's where the excess oil comes from.

Permalink

I used Hepolite Apex rings on my 850 when fitting new rings in the 80's. They had a 3 piece oil control ring. The Wassell Hepolite piston's are moving over to a similar ring made by Goetze. They may supply the rings seperately. The 850 burns no oil to this day.

Permalink

I wonder about 79 bore singles? Perhaps better ask Cox and Turner. Maybe the widths are different?

Permalink

After problems with white smoke on my ‘63 Atlas, I just got the block honed and fitted the old Twiflex oil control rings (two rails with a centre spring photo of piston) and std pistons (slightly marked, some polishing needed). I had fitted new Hepolite pistons with matching rings (slotted ring with a spring type, photo of rings) from the NOC shop. Changing back to the Twiflex rings cured the smoking.

Permalink

Holger, it would be good to see more pics of your seized piston to be certain, but from the clues in the pic you have posted that was most likely a 4 corner seizure which is from an overheated piston. Unless you have fixed what caused the piston to get hot then its liable to happen again. Four corner seizures are not related to rings.

See http://www.marshland.co.nz/ftp/2Strokes/PISTON%2520SEIZURES.pdf

Four corner seizure: Both sides of the piston will show heavy scoring and seizure marks on each side of the wrist pin hole. The pattern of these four seizure points often appears to be a perfect square, hence the slang term "four corner". The scoring takes place in this pattern because those areas of the piston casting are the thickest.

In an air cooled engine the most likely cause is insufficient piston clearance, hopefully you had the bore re-honed and this will have opened up the clearance.

Permalink

When I rebuilt my Electra with 20,000 miles in 2004 I put in new rings without a rebore. Same pistons. Honed bore. One piece oil control ring. Used about a pint every 500 miles. Replaced rings 7000 miles later, when main roller replaced. Did not hone bore. One piece oil control rings never seemed to bed in.

Now at 36,000 miles. Still on original bores and pistons. Ring set with 3 part oil control rings recently fitted and no fall in oil tank level after a 700 mile trip to Hampshire 10 days ago.

These are the same rings as identified as Twiflex above. If you can find them, they really seem better in my limited experience.

Peter

Permalink

Taylor Mattersons when they were open sold an oil control ring, made by Wellworthy. They were part of the AE Associated Engineering Ltd.They were called Duaflex oil control rings. They are of a three piece design, and are 68 x 5/32 x.117 chrome. I have used them in my Dominator engines. I bought many of them back then and i still have some left. 

Permalink

Thanks all. Looks like it cannot do any harm to try the change, if I can find them to fit. I'm not happy with the prospect of cutting wider grooves.

Plenty of other machines use solid rings, so maybe it's really a problem with surface finish. And I must use an air filter...

Permalink

Are your bores worn? How many miles have they done since the last rebore or is it still on its original bore? Just using a flexy hone or the three sprung leg type of hone will only put a fancy surface on the bore. They are more correctly called glaze busters. It wont correct a tapered/oval bore and that is what needs correcting first. Get the bore measured and then decide what needs doing. A proper cylinder hone is one made by Delapena, Not cheap and the use of it will require the bore getting measured with a comparitor (bore gauge)      

Permalink

Speaking only of singles experience here: In a model 50 with a +30 piston and a bore within tolerance; I bought a NOS set of rings from RGM made by Cords of London. These took up the slack and restored a lovely quiet engine. (No re-bore and piston required to achieve the same) 

By the same token, there used to be a top ring called the ridge dodger, or words to that effect.

All I'm saying is that an expensive re-bore isn't always necessary and a step towards a re-sleeve.

Permalink

John - yes, you are right, the ‘four corner’ seizure marks were caused by too tight a clearance on that cylinder. I got both bore (cylinder liner) and pistons checked for roundness, clearance checked and the bore honed to 45thou in an engine shop. The other cylinder was correct, strangely. The one part oil rings certainly weren’t the cause for this, but led to smoking (6-start pump, etc., see older post)

Permalink

The bore dimensions are excellent. No measurable wear using my Mercer bore gauge. Done perhaps 2000 miles since rebore. Surface finish is very glossy with fine vertical streaks (no air filter...I want to change that) but no sign of the fashionable cross hatch marks. I did a glaze busting exercise last year by hand with 300 grade, and it made an immediate improvement in ease of starting (by not oiling the plug if it didn't start 1st or 2nd kick). It also stopped smoking.  But I believe 300 was too fine so I was intending to try 240, and do a more thorough job, because it's back to its old tricks.

It might of course be something else.

Permalink

Honing for cast iron rings is done with 150 to 180 grit, the 3 piece oil control will be a steel ring  but top and middle will be cast iron. So 240 would still be too fine. 

Permalink

That's useful to know. Thanks John.  Compression is excellent, so top rings are good. Oil control seems to be the issue.  It's never been a problem with my Dommie, which has similar solid oil control rings. I think I'll hang on the solid ring anyway.

I wonder if the issue arose because it was treated too gently after the new lining and rebore. That came about because it was not treated gently enough with its previous new piston...and nipped up at 60mph on the A3...what fun!

OEM supplier to Ford, Jaguar, Land Rover and Vauxhall.  A quality supplier of motor industry  components.  I have used their products in many rebuilds with great reliability.

 

J

I do the following.

1. Hone for cast iron

2. Wash the bores repeatably until a white cloth rubbed in the bore comes out spotless.

3. Dry piston assembly with a couple of spots of oil on the front and back of the piston well below the rings.

4. Get the bike started, if timing needs doing then get it over very quickly and do not let the engine idle for any length of time.

5. Get out on the road and vary the throttle with shot bursts of full throttle and no lugging at low revs. This creates the highest combustion pressures which get behind the top two rings to force them out to bed in against the hone.

If all that has been done is new rings then after 100 miles of the above you should be bedded in.

The honing and the rings wear against each other, so lots of debris, so change the oil often. I do the first at 50 miles.

Permalink

All sounds logical. Inevitably expensive, using Morris castor based oil! Not easy with the speed limits around me.

Permalink

Castor oil would not be my choice for a running in oil but the strip down to move from breaking in oil or a cheap supermarket oil to castor does not give you options other than go for castor 30 wt during running in before going to castor 50 wt. Why use Castor on a road bike ?

 


Norton Owners Club Website by 2Toucans