Skip to main content
English French German Italian Spanish

Stuck gearbox bearing

Finally got into the garage with Mike Pemberton's excellent "dismantling the gearbox" DVD. Laydown Box dismantled and mainshaft bearing tapped out but the layshaft bearing will not budge. I've applied heat, bashed the box on the bench top, tried looping a bend of stiff wire under it but all to no avail. It appears to have been "glued" into place.

Other than drilling a couple of small holes behind it and tapping it out (even if I can) I'm at a loss to know what to do. All suggestions very welcome.

George

Permalink

George. Maybe a PO used bearing fit-type Loctite to hold it in place, if it was a poor fit. Are you sure that the bearing needs replacing? If so, more heat, more bashing on a lump of softwood....

Permalink

I think I'd go for the drilling 2 holes method. As long as you do that where there's plenty of meat.

You could then tap them and fill with a couple of grub screws. In fact once they're tapped you could use them as bearing extractors in the future.....

Permalink

I had to get my dolls head casing really hot to move the bearing. You know when it is hot enough when you spit on it and it bounces!

Colin

Permalink

You can buy/borrow/rent blind bearing pullers which might help if you can get one in there. Iâve also heard of people making one using a large Rawl bolt.

dan

Permalink

I used a steel rawbolt expanded in bearing until grips then heat to 400 deg in oven and soak then pull on extractor. Tip put tray in oven to collect oil and best done when wife is out.

Permalink

Thanks guys. Partial success by heating with hot air gun plus butane torch then sticking a lump of blutack down the centre of the bearing and belting the layshaft into the centre. It's come out about 1/16". Another attempt tomorrow. I like the rawlbolt idea -see if I can find one. George

Permalink

I've never failed on gas mark 6 but the casing has to be hot enough for spit to bounce off. Local heating with a small source doesn't seem to get it hot enough all round.

Are the studs out of the box ? If so then you can give it a full two-hander from above your head down onto a softwood block.

Swearing at 'em helps too. :)

Permalink

Each type of Loctite loses strength when hot. At varying temperatures for different types. Its on their web site. Somewhere about 150C I seem to remember but anyway it OUGHT to let go even if it was glued. Anyway if it is hot it probably isn't the Loctite holding it. In theory.

Permalink

Thanks guys. I'll have another go today. Interestingly the oven goes up 230C whilst my hot air gun throws air out at 600C. George

Permalink

The hot air gun may go up to 600c, but, it is localised heat. The oven heats the whole assembly, however, it will probably take about an hour to heat completely. Make sure "her indoors" is just going for the weekly shop!

Permalink

Maplin (while they still exist - shame!) sell an infrared thermometer which is very handy to confirm the temperature of bits of your bike. Ideally I believe it is more accurate when used on a black (or maybe dark grey) surface but I don't really know. Also I don't know what effect heat has on the alloy casting! It might make it stronger ('artificial aging') or weaker. Are there published maxima? And can they be reached in a domestic oven?

I use it at Christmas to check the oven before the turkey goes in!

Permalink

I remember reading somewhere that 200C was about the limit for LM30 alloy which is one of the common ones.

I have one (well 2 as I temporarily lost the first) of those infra red thermometers and it's useful for all sorts of things. You can get them for a tenner or so from ebay. Probably not very accurate but near enough.

Permalink

Yes David, I have one. Used it in my job when I was gainfully employed. Mike Pemberton on his DVD blasts the casing with a pretty hairy blow torch flame and doesn't seem to wqrry about any "heat effect" other than expansion? I've now invested in a Rawlplug (big spender!) so whichever way I heat the box I should be able to get the last part of the bearing out. When it does come out I shall start a new thread on correct bearing size (C2 CN etc). Cheers

George

Permalink

Previously George Phillips wrote:

Yes David, I have one. Used it in my job when I was gainfully employed. Mike Pemberton on his DVD blasts the casing with a pretty hairy blow torch flame and doesn't seem to wqrry about any "heat effect" other than expansion? I've now invested in a Rawlplug (big spender!) so whichever way I heat the box I should be able to get the last part of the bearing out. When it does come out I shall start a new thread on correct bearing size (C2 CN etc). Cheers

George

George; largestexpansion of the alloy will occur up to 230 degrees. I am banned from the kitchen but as the oldgas barbecue is not in use it and itâs got a window in the lid, ideal tool to use with the infrafed temperature gauge.... just sayin

Permalink

Your prompting has persuaded me, Jonathan. I'll dig out my i.r.thermometer and put it to good (and interesting) use. I'm hoping the Rawlplug will serve a good purpose. I'll keep everyone posted in case it helps anyone. George

Permalink

SORTED! No cussing; no oven; just a carefully positioned hot gun and left it for a few minute checking now and again with the I.R. thermometer. A Rawlplug had been screwed in prior to heating (thanks Chris). A slight tug and out it popped!

I now need help on bearing selection so see new thread "Laydown gearbox bearings"

Many thanks for all your comments and interest.

George

Permalink

The plot thickens! Having spoked with Simply Bearings it is now apparent that a PO used a "nearest equivalent" metric bearing for the layshaft inner. Hence my difficulty removing it.

I'm now having trouble sourcing a new bearing - part no. A2/321 which as far as I can tell should be 3/8" thick by 1-9/16" o/d and 11/16" (?). The layshaft measures 0.669" inner and 0/690" outer end. Strangely the parts book for this g/box notes both the inner and outer beatings as having the same part no. yet the two ends of the layshaft have different diameters.

Any suggestions on where I can find this bearing. I'll keep looking anyway.

George

Permalink

Hi George

I have a hand-written note in my maintenance book showing that the layshaft bearing that I removed was a Hoffmann 117 V2 (or maybe VZ). It also says "same as front wheel 6203". Unfortunately no dimensions recorded or what I replaced it with. I am fairly sure that there is a spherical roller bearing only at the clutch end of the layshaft, the other end runs in a plain bush inside the kickstart shaft. Unless someone has come up with a bearing conversion for that end?

You could try these guys:

Vintage Bearing Company http://vintagebearings.co.uk/home/2528957

Hoffmann https://www.hoffmannprecisionbearings.com/

I can't see on-line ordering for either of those so give them a call.

Cheers, Ian McD

Permalink

Thanks Ian. I may end up making phone calls but I'm lacking info. I have several confusions/queries:

1) What are the dimensions of part no.A2/321 -M/shaft RH bearing?

2) What are the correct o/d's of the layshaft - each end?

3) The parts book shows plate item TN77 which I take to be the M/shaft RH bearing, but does not note it in the parts no. section. It simply notes the RH m/shaft bearing as being part no. A2/321 - this is the one for which I have no dimensions. If I get the dimensions I can set about ordering it.

George - sorry about the small print - no idea how to clear it.

Permalink

George

The layshaft L/H bearing is a metric one. The size is 17mm x 40mm x 12mm.

If you look at the WD Norton workshop manual (free download from the WD Norton site) it gives this size. The bearing size did not change throughout, including the AMC box. The later Commando used a roller bearing the same size because the ball type couldn't handle the torque. Not a problem (despite our aspirations) with an ES2. You measured your shaft at 0.669". Multiply this by 25.4 and you get 17mm! (Or as close that matters). It was tight in the casing because they have to be!

I can't help you with the R/H layshaft size but as it runs in the K/S shaft there is no bearing to change.

The WD book quotes the R/H mainshaft bearing as 5/8 x 1 9/16 7/16. This should have a bearing code LJ5/8. Again, I don't think this changed throughout.

Hope this helps.

Colin

Permalink

It's my understanding that the layshaft and front wheel bearings (6203) were always metric. No idea why......

Permalink

Ahh! It's all becoming a bit clearer now. I did a partial assemble and now see that the RH side of the M/shaft does indeed sit inside the kickstart shaft. NOC members - 1; George - Nil.

I was totally misreading the exploded diagram.

Very interesting point from Ian S about metric bearings. Why would they do that? Anyway. it makes sense as all the suppliers keep saying it's a 17mm bearing and here's me thinking "No way. It's a Norton!"

S Bearings are happy to excange the 1-1/8" main bearing (my error) for the correct 1-1/4" and to take back the unused "ghost" RH bearing for the M/shaft so maybe there's a bit of progress ahead!

Thanks for all your input.

George

 


Norton Owners Club Website by 2Toucans