Skip to main content
English French German Italian Spanish

Rocker oil feed

Forums

When loosening the banjo bolts to check for oil feed to the rocker spindles onmy 750 Commando, how much oil should exude? This could be difficult to describe so I'll suggest the following: A) a mizerly dribble, B) a reasonable ooze, C) quickMalcolm, get a cloth!

It's just that on start up with the banjos loose no oilapprears and I'm concerned thatpoor feed to the rockersmay be causing the R/H exhaust valve to seize slightly open as the engine warms. Oil gets into the pipe lower down because when I tried a spare new feed pipe and checked the connection at the back of the timing chest oil ran out. In my experience with my unit Triumph engine the feed to the valve gear is almost instantaneous and the nuts have to be tightened straight-away. The Norton pump was reconditioned and the engine does not wet-sump (like it did back in the eighties). Should I remove the timing cover to check the sealing washers? The oil tank feed pipes are all good (the bike is fitted with a cartridge filter) and connected correctly as per the parts diagram (bearing in mind that the labellingof the feed and return pipes are transposed in the 750 parts diagram!)

Other observations are that the return to the tank on start up is not a spurt (again like on my Triumph) but a 'spit' that suggests that there is air in the oil. Is this normal for a Commando? I've clocked up more than 100 miles since the rebuild so I can't believe the pump isn't working properly. Any ideas guys?

Permalink

Alright Neil, when turning my Mk3 engine minus cylinder headover by hand oil pumps out of the rocker feed pipe. Don't know the actual flow rate but it is sufficient to make a mess on the rest of the engine unless the end is temporary capped or wrapped in cloth, hope this helps,

Simon.

Permalink

The scavenge side of the oil pump has a larger capacity than the feed side, so air bubbles will always be visible in the return flow. This is normal, so don't worry about it.

As for the rocker feed oil flow, how long do you let the engine run before you kill it again? Depending on how long the engine has been standing it could take a while for oil to arrive at the top. But this is pure speculation, since I haven't tested or observed it on my own 1972 Commando Roadster.

Permalink

Hi Neil

Answer C.

The rocker feed is from the pressure side of the oil pump,so if you have delay to the rockers you have a delay to the crankshaft as well not good!!!

Kev

Permalink

Thanks for your replies chaps. I've got a horrible feeling that I've incorrectly fitted the cartridge filter in the FEED line!! I thought it was the labelling in the parts diagram that was wrong but as described in:

"The factory parts manual shows it all incorrectly" (see Commando Technical Section).

Les Scourse states that the filter (and I presume he means the cartridge filter) is in the RETURN line.

So, if the RETURN does go from the back of the tank to the cartridge filter and then to the INSIDE pipe of the oil junction block and the FEED is the continuous pipe from the banjo to the OUTSIDE pipe of the oil junction block, mine has been connected wrongly. This would certainly explain the lack of oil in the rocker feed pipe - arrgh!!!

Half of me wants someone to say, nope you're correct and half of me wants someone to say yep, that's where your problem is. Come on chaps, put me out of my misery!

Permalink

Hi Neil.

The outlet from the oil tank (Big Banjo bolt)goes to right hand/outer pipe of the junction block.

The left/inner pipe of the junction block goes to the inlet side of the screw on oil filter mount,then from the outlet side of screw on oil filter to the inlet/return pipe of the oil tank.

As I said before the rocker oil feed is high pressure from the oil pump so do not use any old pipe for this line, must the proper high pressure pipe !!!

Hope this helps.

Kev

Permalink

I RECENTLY HAD NO OIL PRESSURE FEEDING ROCKERS,SO I REMOVED LOWER BANJO OIL FEED, AND USING OIL CAN PUMPED OIL BACK THROUGH CASING TO OIL PUMP,THIS PRESSURISED OIL PUMP,AND THEN STARTED BIKE WITH PIPE OFF ,THEN OIL CAME OUT WITH FULL PRESSURE.I WOULD RECOMEND PUTTING OIL THROUGH ROCKER SHAFTS FIRST IF NO OIL HAS BEEN FEEDING VALVES ETC

Permalink

You've been informed correctly that the oil filter is fittedon the return from junction block to filter and filter to tank, and yes the flow is straight from the tank to junction block. Importantly this means whilst you've had no or limitedflow to the rockers theres been no or limitedflow to the big ends too. The filter would create resistance to oil flow, hopefully the pump has been able to suck enough oil through the filter to provide adequate lubrication to the big ends.I think an engine strip to check the big ends is required, for peace of mind at least.

Simon.

Permalink

Ok I hear what you say and I know how stupid my mistake was but there must have been enough lubrication to avoid serious damage because there was no metal contamination in the engine oil. Somehow, even with the hampered engine, I've managed to clock nearly 400 miles since the rebuild was completed. The oil was Castrol XL20W/50 and a professional mechanic friend of mine said the additives in modern oils, including those intended for classic machinery, provide high levels of protection. Anyway, I've obviously reassembled the plumbing correctly plus I've replaced the cartridge oil filter and am just waiting on a delivery from Castrol before I test the motor. I'm pretty confident that it'll be ok. I'll let you know how it goes.The publishers of that parts manual have a lot to answer for. I wonder how many Commando engines have been totalled by their negligence? Hopefully the bruises from kicking myself will heal soon!
Permalink

I feel sick to the pit of my stomach because I've just started the engine and, although feed to the rockers is now good and the return is normal, the engine smokes especially from the left cylinder and I can hear the plugs fouling the longer I run the motor. I have been rebuilding my Commando on-and-off since 1985 (yep, nineteen eighty five) and now it looks like I've caused some serious damage by making an elementary mistake. I'm hoping premature wear will be confined to the valve guides and not the cylinder bores or worse, the big ends. I suppose I have to be thankful the engine didn't seize and do some catastrophic damage. If anyone can tell me how the engine managed several hundred miles like this please explain. I'm sure we'd all like to know?
Permalink

Previously wrote:

I feel sick to the pit of my stomach because I've just started the engine and, although feed to the rockers is now good and the return is normal, the engine smokes especially from the left cylinder and I can hear the plugs fouling the longer I run the motor. I have been rebuilding my Commando on-and-off since 1985 (yep, nineteen eighty five) and now it looks like I've caused some serious damage by making an elementary mistake. I'm hoping premature wear will be confined to the valve guides and not the cylinder bores or worse, the big ends. I suppose I have to be thankful the engine didn't seize and do some catastrophic damage. If anyone can tell me how the engine managed several hundred miles like this please explain. I'm sure we'd all like to know?

Hi Neil,

I sympathize with you on this one. I guess its no great comfort to you, but I did exactly the same on rebuilding my Matchless G80 ten years ago. Despite having studied drawings and diagrams I managed to connect the oil lines the wrong way around! After the first 5 miles the piston nipped up and scored the cylinder. Mind you this was a standard bore cylinder with a standard n.o.s. wirewound piston, that I had gone to great lengths to source. Of course a rebore and new piston was needed, but the bigend and crankshaft bearings survived, 15.000 miles later they are still good and running fine. They probably survived because I flooded the bottom end and rocker box with oil before starting up, but also because ball bearings with their relative smaller area of metal to metal contact are less sensitive to oil shortage. What I'm trying to say is that your worst case scenario could be "just" a rebore and new guides, but a strip down of the topend must be done to asses damage. I'm still at a loss to explain your several hundred miles of initial running in! Good luck and lets hear how it goes!

 


Norton Owners Club Website by 2Toucans