I currently have a 6 start worm gear oil pump drive fitted which is incorrect for my 1956 Dominator. When I built this engine I used the parts I had which was the 6 start gear and a driven gear which fits on the end of the oil pump. This was 1998 and as I recall, I could find no reference marks on the driven gear to identify whether it matched with a 3 start, 6 start, or both, worm gear. I intend to go back to the 3 start gear as they are available but not sure if my driven gear will be ok. Can anyone advise how you can tell what worm the driven gear matchesand, if there are two types of driven gear, where I might obtain a 3 start worm compatible one?
many thanks
Jon
The gears are in matched p…
- Log in to post comments
Previously Gordon Johnston…
Previously Gordon Johnston wrote:
The gears are in matched pairs. The 6 start is not compatible with the 3 start gear. Some people did fit 6 start gears to their standard Dominators - there was nothing to be gained from it so reverting to 3 start makes sense. Just make sure your rocker oil feed is from the return to the tank (as it should be) and that you have scrolled rocker spindles.
Key questions are how do you tell the difference between the driven gears and where can I get 3 start compatible one?
- Log in to post comments
Hopefully attached or near…
Hopefully attached or nearby will be 2 pages from an old Roadholder which should answer a lot of your questions.
Despite the diagrams being a bit non-scale the difference between the angles of the worms is fairly obvious. The 6 start pair have a steeper angle to the worm.
To test that you have a matched pair....balance the gear on top of the worm so that they are meshing. They should be at right angles to each other, as they would be in use on the engine. If they do not make a clear right angle then there is possibly a mix of 3 and 6 start bits. Mixed components will make an angle around 80* ( or 100*).
The oil pump driven gear was generally marked with a 6 on its end but not always.
Attachments oil-pump-ch1-bmp- Log in to post comments
Attached is next page of R…
Attached is next page of Roadholder Oil Pump Article. Page 4 (not attached) has all the part numbers.
The NOC spares Scheme sells these kinds of parts.
Attachments oil-pump-ch2-bmp- Log in to post comments
Thanks Phil this is very h…
Thanks Phil this is very helpful. Can you advise which copy of Roadholder this is so I can see the Part Nos. Hoperfully I haven't been running for 15years with unmatched gears!
- Log in to post comments
Impossible to run with mis…
Impossible to run with mismatched gears - they just wouldn't mesh.
- Log in to post comments
Previously jon_osborne wro…
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
I currently have a 6 start worm gear oil pump drive fitted which is incorrect for my 1956 Dominator. When I built this engine I used the parts I had which was the 6 start gear and a driven gear which fits on the end of the oil pump. This was 1998 and as I recall, I could find no reference marks on the driven gear to identify whether it matched with a 3 start, 6 start, or both, worm gear. I intend to go back to the 3 start gear as they are available but not sure if my driven gear will be ok. Can anyone advise how you can tell what worm the driven gear matchesand, if there are two types of driven gear, where I might obtain a 3 start worm compatible one?
many thanks
Jon
Hi john, I have a matching 3 start set-up,, interested in a swap? I am in N Lincs.
- Log in to post comments
Previously terry_odlin wro…
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
I currently have a 6 start worm gear oil pump drive fitted which is incorrect for my 1956 Dominator. When I built this engine I used the parts I had which was the 6 start gear and a driven gear which fits on the end of the oil pump. This was 1998 and as I recall, I could find no reference marks on the driven gear to identify whether it matched with a 3 start, 6 start, or both, worm gear. I intend to go back to the 3 start gear as they are available but not sure if my driven gear will be ok. Can anyone advise how you can tell what worm the driven gear matchesand, if there are two types of driven gear, where I might obtain a 3 start worm compatible one?
many thanks
Jon
Hi john, I have a matching 3 start set-up,, interested in a swap? I am in N Lincs.
- Log in to post comments
Hi Terry, I was just going…
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
- Log in to post comments
Previously Gordon Johnston…
Previously Gordon Johnston wrote:
Attachments picture-004-jpgImpossible to run with mismatched gears - they just wouldn't mesh.
Gordon.......for the very first time evr (I think)I am going to have to slightly disagree with you. Having many years ago dismantled an engine which had a 6 start worm on the crank but a 3 start gear on the pump. Somebody had told the owner that his engine would have a better oil feed with a 6 start set-up. The guy had changed one of the set but did not realize he needed to change both. The engine was incredibly stiff to turn over, which was why I was called in, but had been running. On inspection both gears had chewed the life out of each other and were only fit for the scap bin.
Attached photo shows what the respective pairings should resemble when correct and when wrongly matched.
- Log in to post comments
Phil, I find this allm a b…
Phil, I find this allm a bit confusing. If the teeth on the driven gear are fitting between the teeth of the worm in your mismatch picture (3start worm with 6 start driven?), then the teeth are almost parallel with the axis of the oil pump shaft. If teeth on a 6 start driven are ~parallel with the oil pump shaft, then they would not be fitting into the teeth of the worm of the 6 start matched pair in your picture. Am I missing something here?
- Log in to post comments
Previously jon_osborne wro…
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
hello Ian give me a call on 07519710121 any day before 8.00pm, the gears that I have are in very good order, If you let me have your address, will send them to you and if you dont want them just post them back to me, or send your set. Terry
- Log in to post comments
I too am in central Scotla…
I too am in central Scotland and have 3 start gears if you want them. When you fit the oil pump, the pump gears engage with the gears on the crankshaft. If someone forced a 6 start onto a 3 start gear, it would require astonishing brutality. Ouch. Gordon.
- Log in to post comments
Previously Gordon Johnston…
Previously Gordon Johnston wrote:
I too am in central Scotland and have 3 start gears if you want them. When you fit the oil pump, the pump gears engage with the gears on the crankshaft. If someone forced a 6 start onto a 3 start gear, it would require astonishing brutality. Ouch. Gordon.
Gordon, thanks for the offer...what condition are the gears in and where are you. I amin Stirling. Am trying to follow through with Terry's offer at the moment but I have also ordered (or not due to computer glitch) a pair from NOC. Will keep yours as reserve if that is OK. Would you want the 6 start pairing that come out?
Jon
- Log in to post comments
Hi Jon, I'm near Biggar.…
Hi Jon, I'm near Biggar. I'll go and have a dig in my oil pump drawer to check condition but they will be in good order. I'll check if I have any 6 starts. If not I am sure I can find a home for them. My bike has a wiring glitch - no llights earlier this week - so I am attacking it with a multimeter to find the cause. Doesn't stop it starting first kick though - I do love magnetos. Gordon.
- Log in to post comments
Previously terry_odlin wro…
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
hellojon give me a call on 07519710121 any day before 8.00pm, the gears that I have are in very good order, If you let me have your address, will send them to you and if you dont want them just post them back to me, or send your set. Terry
Hello Jon, gears were posted today(wednesday) Terry
- Log in to post comments
Previously terry_odlin wro…
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
hellojon give me a call on 07519710121 any day before 8.00pm, the gears that I have are in very good order, If you let me have your address, will send them to you and if you dont want them just post them back to me, or send your set. Terry
Hello Jon, gears were posted today(wednesday) Terry
Hi Terry, Gears arrived yesterday (Sat.). Thanks, will be in touch when I have swapped them. Regards Jon
- Log in to post comments
Previously jon_osborne wro…
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
hellojon give me a call on 07519710121 any day before 8.00pm, the gears that I have are in very good order, If you let me have your address, will send them to you and if you dont want them just post them back to me, or send your set. Terry
Hello Jon, gears were posted today(wednesday) Terry
Hi Terry, Gears arrived yesterday (Sat.). Thanks, will be in touch when I have swapped them. Regards Jon
Latest update on this is that I have now taken my engine apart - slight rub on LH cylinder (fitted with JP pistons) but thats another story - and removed the oil pump and driving worm. The photos show the 'as fitted' 6 start worm and driven gear along with the matched 3 start pair from Terry Odlin. Clearly my driven gear as fitted is running around 5-10Deg from its expected natural centreline and has been in service like this for at least 4,000miles. The gears are shown deeply engaged and when fitted to the bike are less engaged allowing the gear to twist and sit on its centreline.
Terry, my driven gear is the same as yours and so I cannot send you a matched 6 start pair. Do you still want the pair; they were running ok after all?
Finally, by returning to a 3 start gear I will half the oil flow to the engine. Given it has partially seized on the LH side is halving the oil flow a good idea??
Attachments Dommie%20oil%20gears.JPG dommie-oil-gears-2-jpg- Log in to post comments
Previously jon_osborne wro…
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
hellojon give me a call on 07519710121 any day before 8.00pm, the gears that I have are in very good order, If you let me have your address, will send them to you and if you dont want them just post them back to me, or send your set. Terry
Hello Jon, gears were posted today(wednesday) Terry
Hi Terry, Gears arrived yesterday (Sat.). Thanks, will be in touch when I have swapped them. Regards Jon
Latest update on this is that I have now taken my engine apart - slight rub on LH cylinder (fitted with JP pistons) but thats another story - and removed the oil pump and driving worm. The photos show the 'as fitted' 6 start worm and driven gear along with the matched 3 start pair from Terry Odlin. Clearly my driven gear as fitted is running around 5-10Deg from its expected natural centreline and has been in service like this for at least 4,000miles. The gears are shown deeply engaged and when fitted to the bike are less engaged allowing the gear to twist and sit on its centreline.
Terry, my driven gear is the same as yours and so I cannot send you a matched 6 start pair. Do you still want the pair; they were running ok after all?
Finally, by returning to a 3 start gear I will half the oil flow to the engine. Given it has partially seized on the LH side is halving the oil flow a good idea??
Hi Jon, just send my original parts back please!
Have a great new year!!
Terry
- Log in to post comments
Previously terry_odlin wro…
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
hellojon give me a call on 07519710121 any day before 8.00pm, the gears that I have are in very good order, If you let me have your address, will send them to you and if you dont want them just post them back to me, or send your set. Terry
Hello Jon, gears were posted today(wednesday) Terry
Hi Terry, Gears arrived yesterday (Sat.). Thanks, will be in touch when I have swapped them. Regards Jon
Latest update on this is that I have now taken my engine apart - slight rub on LH cylinder (fitted with JP pistons) but thats another story - and removed the oil pump and driving worm. The photos show the 'as fitted' 6 start worm and driven gear along with the matched 3 start pair from Terry Odlin. Clearly my driven gear as fitted is running around 5-10Deg from its expected natural centreline and has been in service like this for at least 4,000miles. The gears are shown deeply engaged and when fitted to the bike are less engaged allowing the gear to twist and sit on its centreline.
Terry, my driven gear is the same as yours and so I cannot send you a matched 6 start pair. Do you still want the pair; they were running ok after all?
Finally, by returning to a 3 start gear I will half the oil flow to the engine. Given it has partially seized on the LH side is halving the oil flow a good idea??
Hi Jon, just send my original parts back please!
Have a great new year!!
Terry
Gears posted today Tues 31st. Will buy a 3 Start from the NOC
Happy new year to all
Best-regards
Jon
- Log in to post comments
Previously jon_osborne wro…
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously terry_odlin wrote:
Previously jon_osborne wrote:
Hi Terry,
I was just going to buy the matching pair on NOC spares now I have seen the driven gear. Happy to give you what comes off (6 start pair) when I take the bike apart.
Let me know if you are interested - I am in Central Scotland
hellojon give me a call on 07519710121 any day before 8.00pm, the gears that I have are in very good order, If you let me have your address, will send them to you and if you dont want them just post them back to me, or send your set. Terry
Hello Jon, gears were posted today(wednesday) Terry
Hi Terry, Gears arrived yesterday (Sat.). Thanks, will be in touch when I have swapped them. Regards Jon
Latest update on this is that I have now taken my engine apart - slight rub on LH cylinder (fitted with JP pistons) but thats another story - and removed the oil pump and driving worm. The photos show the 'as fitted' 6 start worm and driven gear along with the matched 3 start pair from Terry Odlin. Clearly my driven gear as fitted is running around 5-10Deg from its expected natural centreline and has been in service like this for at least 4,000miles. The gears are shown deeply engaged and when fitted to the bike are less engaged allowing the gear to twist and sit on its centreline.
Terry, my driven gear is the same as yours and so I cannot send you a matched 6 start pair. Do you still want the pair; they were running ok after all?
Finally, by returning to a 3 start gear I will half the oil flow to the engine. Given it has partially seized on the LH side is halving the oil flow a good idea??
Hi Jon, just send my original parts back please!
Have a great new year!!
Terry
Gears posted today Tues 31st. Will buy a 3 Start from the NOC
Happy new year to all
Best-regards
Jon
Hi Jon, gears arrived safely today, thank you - Terry
- Log in to post comments
The gears are in matched pairs. The 6 start is not compatible with the 3 start gear. Some people did fit 6 start gears to their standard Dominators - there was nothing to be gained from it so reverting to 3 start makes sense. Just make sure your rocker oil feed is from the return to the tank (as it should be) and that you have scrolled rocker spindles.